Blog Reviews

July 1, 2009 by Tarquin Hall Leave a reply »

“The Case of the Man Who Died Laughing”

“Sometimes a reviewer gets lucky. A book will find its way into your hands that you may not have seen scanning the vast shelves of a massive bookstore. And that book charms you. It renders you mentally content, so sated, that your faith in reading crime fiction is renewed. THE CASE OF THE MAN WHO DIED LAUGHING…is such a magical tome.” CRIMESPREE MAG.COM


“The setting is Delhi, India, where it’s even hotter and more humid than Alvin, Texas, and Hall does a great job of getting that across. In fact, he does so well with the setting that it’s almost like being there. He captures the language, too, and that’s another part of the book’s charm… The book is funny, the mystery is complex, and the pace is quick. Check it out.” BILL CRIDER”S POP CULTURE MAGAZINE

“All the while I was reading this book, I had a sort of silly smile stuck to my face… Hilarious and topical just like the first one, with a touch of the bizarre to boot.” NISHITA’S RANTS AND RAVES

“It is so refreshing to have read a mystery that doesn’t rely on the cliches of a “bumbling detective” whose assistant modestly and quietly solves the mystery for him or the heroine on the wrong end of a barrel of a gun who needs to be rescued right as she figures out who done it.  All the females present are more than capable of uncovering dirt and getting out of danger on their own.” STACKED

“The Case of the Missing Servant”:

“The story is complex, fast-paced with hilarious and touching moments while looking at Indian culture. Puri’s investigations take him from the country clubs and mansions of the wealthy classes to the squalor and poverty of the slums of Delhi and Jharkhand. In the end, Puri has done what he could with the majority of his cases closed and the missing servant located in a manner befitting Perry Mason.” BARBARA MARTIN

“This was a quirky book, filled with much humor. But it also had great detective stories and a great character in Puri, who, for all his faults, has a mind equal to Sherlock Holmes or Poirot.” LOST IN BOOKS

“Charming, witty, clever and atmospheric, Hall’s foray into fiction is a winner.” MOSTLY FICTION

“It’s to the author’s credit he paints all his characters in the round. We see their uniquely Indian faults and virtues. We don’t experience intense thrills or chills, complicated twists and turns, or white-knuckled tension in this book. But for an armchair excursion to an exotic locale, seen from the inside out, for characters we develop an exasperated affection for, it’s perfect.” BEWILDERING STORIES

“The story is sometimes comical, continuously suspenseful, and endlessly fascinating for its detailed depiction of how middle-class Indians live, eat, and navigate through the punishing traffic and the vicissitudes of a bureaucracy gone wild.’ Mal Warwick’s Blog

‘Several reviews I read compared this to Alexander McCall Smith’s No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency novels, and it’s true that both feature charming detectives in exotic locales. But in Puri, Tarquin Hall has created an endearing detective all his own. If the comparison gets him a wider readership, then I’m all for it, but the book is entertaining enough on its own not to need any coattails.’ A LIFE DIVIDED

‘Hall…has a silky smooth style, ripe with colorful descriptions and honest dialogue.’ BOOKGASM

‘A who-dun-it with Indian Tadka can not get better than this. Not at all over the top, has lovable characters & the taut writing makes the book an immensely entertaining read. I am now waiting for a series of cases to follow. So go grab your copy NOW!!!’ BOOKS, LIFE N MORE

‘Hall is able to bring to life the social complexities of the large, polyglot country. The divide between rich and poor, the confusion and dislocation of Delhi, the rigidly stratified social system – Hall builds them all up around Puri so we understand not only the detective, but the world he lives in.’ THE DIE IS CAST

‘A delightful mystery that immerses the reader in contemporary Indian culture. Readers of the No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency series will be thrilled to find a book that combines a foreign locale and an engaging main character with a humorous/cozy bent.’ POP GOES FICTION

‘I enjoyed Chubby’s philosophizing (he also writes letters to the Times) about the woes of modern India as much as the cleverly plotted mystery. Vish Puri, Most Private Investigator is tremendous (at times even farcical) fun – where else would you find a PI whose wife admonishes “Danger doesn’t worry me…but those deadly pakoras and chicken frankies you like so much do.” Don’t miss this one!’ BOOKLOONS

Advertisement

11 Responses

  1. “The Case of the Missing Servant” is an excellent first novel… as good as Inspector Ghoti. Better than this summer’s Evanovich’s “Finger Lickin’ Fifteen” and Baldacci’s “Stone Cold.” As good as Inspector Ghoti.

    Two small suggestions:

    On page 3, change “as labor intensive as they came” to “as labor intensive as they come,” notwithstanding the past tense of the sentence. (In the OED, under the definition of the verb “come,” see Signification 13d: “as — as they come.”)

    Although Simon & Schuster correctly changed most British spelling, etc., for the American edition, they failed to change “tannoy” to “loudspeaker” or “public address” on page 219.

  2. dot soskin says:

    Hello,
    I just finished your book The Case of the missing Servant and thoroughly enjoyed it!
    I really got the feel of India and just loved the fear of flying description.
    Kind Regards,
    Dot Soskin

  3. kitty mom says:

    I was lucky enough to spot The Case of the Missing Servant on the new book shelf of my local library. Thoroughly enjoyed reading about Chubby, his operatives, his family, and his techniques which are real, not made up like Sherlock Holmes. Can’t wait for round 2.

  4. Jody Bennett says:

    I quit reading after page 6 when America was blamed for the immorality in India. Morality or the lack thereof is a personal choice. There are immoral people in America as well as people of great integrity, so you lost this reader by blaming the woes of the world on America. Shame on you!

  5. L. Gayle Daneliuk says:

    A great read! Vish Puri has now taken a place with some of my favorites! Kaminsky’s Rosnikov, Grimes Richard Jury, Christie’s Poirot . Sincerely hope the next story is in the works .Thanks

  6. fatima says:

    I thoroughly enjoyed reading about vish puri and his sidekicks and their adventures. You cant help falling in love with the characters. I love reading mysteries and cant wait for the new novel! The writing style, humour is really enjoyable. I would like to know when the new novel will be released in South Africa? Really excited about it.
    Thank you..

  7. Nan says:

    Just a quick note to say I loved the book and wrote about it on my blog in November 2009:

    http://lettersfromahillfarm.blogspot.com/2009/11/case-of-missing-servant-by-tarquin-hall.html

  8. Bruce says:

    “The Case of the Missing Servant” is an excellent first novel… as good as Inspector Ghoti. Better than this summer’s Evanovich’s “Finger Lickin’ Fifteen” and Baldacci’s “Stone Cold.” As good as Inspector Ghoti.

    Two small suggestions:

    On page 3, change “as labor intensive as they came” to “as labor intensive as they come,” notwithstanding the past tense of the sentence. (In the OED, under the definition of the verb “come,” see Signification 13d: “as — as they come.”)

    Although Simon & Schuster correctly changed most British spelling, etc., for the American edition, they failed to change “tannoy” to “loudspeaker” or “public address” on page 219.

  9. Bruce says:

    I was lucky enough to spot The Case of the Missing Servant on the new book shelf of my local library. Thoroughly enjoyed reading about Chubby, his operatives, his family, and his techniques which are real, not made up like Sherlock Holmes. Can’t wait for round 2.

  10. Steve says:

    A great read! Vish Puri has now taken a place with some of my favorites! Kaminsky’s Rosnikov, Grimes Richard Jury, Christie’s Poirot . Sincerely hope the next story is in the works .Thanks

  11. Amy says:

    I was lucky enough to spot The Case of the Missing Servant on the new book shelf of my local library. Thoroughly enjoyed reading about Chubby, his operatives, his family, and his techniques which are real, not made up like Sherlock Holmes. Can’t wait for round 2.

Leave a Reply